Jan 04, · A Civil Action. The movie, A Civil Action was based on a real court case, Anderson V Cryovac. This movie shows the story of court case through Jan Schlichtmann. Jan Schlichtmann, played by John Travolta, is a very successful that belongs to a well known law firm Essay about A Civil Action Words | 4 Pages. time. To compound such tragedies, imagine being poisoned yourself and having to fight some of the largest local corporations to prove the truth and get it stopped. This is the community setting for Jonathan Harr's true-to A Civil Action Essay. Shelby Tietjen. Mr. Como. Business Law. 22 December A Civil Action. This movie began with Jan Schlichtmann, a successful lawyer, was approached by a group of unhappy families. These families all had children that had died of leukemia, they believe from the river, and they wanted Schlichtmann to fight for them
A Civil Action - Movie Essay Example For FREE �� - New York Essays
The Marxist approach can best explain the process and outcome of the case in A Civil Action. Section 1: Karl Marx sided with three principles regarding law and how it relates to the upper and lower classes in society. They are: law is a product of evolving economic forces; law is a tool used by the ruling class to maintain its power over the lower class and the means of production are owned by the ruling class. Marx believed that law is a structure of power. In this case the victims of families were the working class and the powerful corporations such as Beatrice Foods and W.
Grace and Company are the ruling class. These two companies own their means of production meaning they do not need resources from others in a civil action essay to keep their businesses running smoothly. Facher and Cheeseman, the defendants of the case, knew that the opposing side was not set financially. This way it is even more difficult to find flaws in the company and reveal their mistakes. However this case does relate to a Marxist approach when dealing with the conflict theory. Marx believed that the bourgeoisie would always rule over the proletariat unless the members of proletariat would rise up and rebel against the ruling class. The bourgeoisie in A Civil Action committed crimes of dumping toxic waste and illegally withholding information.
His lawyers within the firm left after they decided the firm was not working collectively as a team. The two huge corporations admitted that they had done wrong and also provided funds in hopes of the situation not happening again. Between 15 years after the a civil action essay incident, a civil action essay children around the city of Woburn die from the effects of leukemia. When Anne Anderson and other affected families presented their situation to Schlichtmann, they said they would be content with an apology from the responsible party. Despite the need for more money in a large case like this, Jan Schlichtmann and a civil action essay firm stop working on all cases except the Anne Anderson at el.
His firm began to have no other income for the expenses of the case, a civil action essay. Grace and Company for the a civil action essay of children these families had to deal with, a civil action essay. Originally when this case a civil action essay presented to the major firms in the area, no one wanted accept the case. It was unwanted, a civil action essay, so it became known as orphan case because it was believed that there would be no financial gain from the case. Similar to an orphan waiting to be brought into a home, there were many victims waiting to be brought justice by a lawyer.
Many personal injury lawyers are viewed in the public a civil action essay bottom feeders or vultures that prey on the misfortunes of others. For example, a civil action essay, in the beginning of the film there a civil action essay a scene where Schlichtmann sees a man holding his head after a car accident. The lawyer from Cornell Schlichtmann instantly gives the man in pain his business and tells him to call him for financially pursuing the person who inflicted the pain. This was due to the fact that representing dead children in court will provide the least amount of financial gain.
A dead person is less valuable compared to a severely maimed person. A woman is less valuable that a man; A single person is less valuable than a married one. A rich person is more valuable than a poor person, while being a black victim is less valuable than being white victim. Civil court is where the money lies within the justice system. Civil actions cases are worth more than criminal cases. Many firms were afraid to go after the big corporations on the opposition but not Schlichtmann. Jan Schlichtmann, Kevin Conway and Bill Crowley represent the plaintiffs. A financial advisor in the firm also accompanies them, a civil action essay. The main two lawyers that represent the defendants are Jerome Facher Beatrice Foods and Will Cheeseman W. Grace and Company. The lawyers solely handled the case and a jury decided the outcomes.
Lawyers decide how to approach cases and arguments rather than the victims choose what points to argue and what not to argue. If a settlement occurs or is close to occurring lawyers have the decision to claim the price they want or continue to negotiate. Each lawyer has intimate a civil action essay within the system. There are a few more people involved with the case such as the Judge Walker Skinner, prosecutors, police and jurors. Upon examination of the Schlichtmann firm it seems as if the three lawyers and the financial advisor operate as a unit because of the similarities of being lawyers and dealing with the same a civil action essay in their firm. But if a person were to examine how effectively the group acts on a constant basis, things are not as easy as it seems.
When it came time to settle the Schlichtmann firm was given two opportunities. The defendants instantly deny the settlement offer and have their minds set on getting the case tried in a courtroom. About a week later they end up accepting the settlement due to the fact that the Schlichtmann firm was so broke that they were close a civil action essay filing bankruptcy. These two miscommunications about settlements shows that the firm is not as perfect as it seems. If the lawyers within the firm cannot discuss and come to agreements with lawyers in the firm, they are not working as a cohesive group. The social status of these players places them at the top of the list because they are white middle age males with important professions, being lawyers, a civil action essay.
As the movie goes on, there is a trend that the lawyers do not go home even to sleep or eat. Most of the time, they are in the work place and work in a sense becomes the home facility. In the community all those who know and understand the importance of being a lawyer respect these lawyers. The first way is because they are a firm that files civil suits, giving them the option to help people in the community. The second way they are integrated in the community is through the status of the firm. The firm does not have many resources so it does not look to represent national corporations in lawsuits but rather individuals or small families within Massachusetts who need some financial aid, a civil action essay.
The better networking a lawyer has, it makes it easier for them to obtain resources to further a case. In the justice system, there are many people who have Ivy League law degrees giving lawyers a chance to connect with the judges. Since many judges were former prosecutors, they may have a connection to lawyers that approach their stand and may tend to agree with their statements. For example, the networking obtained from having an Ivy League degree can boost the chances of that person winning a case. People that graduate with a professional degree from an Ivy League school are sought after in the real world.
There are constant email blasts from Ivy League graduates to fellow graduates about job offerings or help offered within the community of the graduate a civil action essay. In A Civil Action, there is a scene where Jan Schlichtmann gets invited to the Harvard Club of Law in New York by one of the Grace executives named Al Eustis. Al Eustis is a Harvard graduate and assumes that Schlichtmann is a Harvard graduate as well because he received information from a friend stating that. When Schlichtmann arrives to the Harvard Club he makes it clear that he is not to be confused with a Harvard graduate because he received his law degree from Cornell University. Eustis almost tries to deny Schlichtmann and does not hear what he has to say simply because he went to a rival school, Cornell3.
If Schlichtmann had been in the same situation but been a Harvard graduate the settlement probably would have gone up and Eustis would have been more friendly and open to hearing any information. This is how lawyers feel when dealing with the opposing side enemy. Each lawyer from the case knows the same amount of background information but each player also has information that they do not want the opposing side to know about. Lawyers approach a lawsuit as if it is war. Then there is a battle. Players that are dealing with the case risk a lot financially and emotionally but the chances of winning give the lawyers a reason to stay involved with the case.
It is all a game and the winner takes all. Free Essays Topics Essay Checker Hire Writer Login. Free essay samples Movie A Civil Action — Movie. A Civil Action — A civil action essay 1 January Hire verified writer. A Civil Action — Movie Essay Example. Related Essays. Civil Action A Civil Action Term Paper Harr's A Civil Action Industrial Tort Law Affirmative Action: A Program Of Positive Action… Affirmative Action: A Program Of Positive Action Home Movie Is Better Than Theater Movie Civil Right and Civil Liberties Action Films Action Films Action Research Affirmative action, a civil action essay. A limited a civil action essay offer! Save Time On Research and Writing.
Get My Paper, a civil action essay. Popular Topics gender celebrity starbucks jewellery nutrition leadership arranged marriage mobile phone hiphop customer service.
How to Analyze Supplemental Jurisdiction on a Civil Procedure Essay
, time: 23:20A Civil Action Essay | bltietjen
A Civil Action Essay. The movie, A Civil Action is a perfect representation of trial procedure. This movie shows the story of court case through Jan Schlichtmann. Jan Schlichtmann is a very successful lawyer that belongs to a well-known law firm. Schlichtmann law firm is approached by a group of unhappy families that resided in Woburn, Massachusetts Essays on A Civil Action. Essay examples. Essay topics. Filter. Clear filters apply filters cancel. A Book Report on a Civil Action by Jonathan Harr. words | 4 Pages. A Civil Action Term Paper In Johnathan Harr’s book, A Civil Action, several children became diagnosed with Leukemia in the very small town of Woburn, Massachusetts. When A Civil Action Essay. Shelby Tietjen. Mr. Como. Business Law. 22 December A Civil Action. This movie began with Jan Schlichtmann, a successful lawyer, was approached by a group of unhappy families. These families all had children that had died of leukemia, they believe from the river, and they wanted Schlichtmann to fight for them
No comments:
Post a Comment